# DEV-SYN-03 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** [Public packet](../public/DEV-SYN-03-mural-attribution.md). Hand-authored evidence key, not a completed participant memo. Apply [common conventions](README.md). | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | Combined maximum 650 words; proposed catalogue paragraph maximum 80 words plus supporting memo. No required wording or heading names. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | Commission 1912, installation 1914, restoration 1961; these are not interchangeable creation dates. | S1:L1; S3:L1; S4:L1 | | C3 | R3 | Vale is a documented commission coordinator, not a confirmed artist. | S1:L1; S5:L1 | | C4 | R4 | Dass claims assistance to an unnamed painter; role details and painter identity remain unknown. | S2:L1 | | C5 | R5 | Newspaper wording is ambiguous here and lacks corroborating authorship evidence. It is not ignored or elevated into proof. | S2:L2; S5:L1 | | C6 | R6 | Photograph supports existence/installation by its accepted 1914 date, not artist identity. | S3:L2 | | C7 | R7 | 20 + 35 + 45 = 100 nominal crowns; Market Trust contributes 45.0%. Funding is not artist credit or modern monetary value. | S1:L2 | | C8 | R8 | Catalogue identifies authorship as unresolved/unknown. Optional wording attributing a claim specifically to the later caption must stay unconfirmed. No required favored artist. | S4:L2; S5:L1 | | C9 | R9 | Original completion in 1961 is contradicted by an installed mural in 1914; correcting the date does not independently settle authorship. | S3:L1-L2; S4:L1-L2 | | C10 | R10 | Dated records govern event dates, but an early newspaper's ambiguous wording still has limited evidential scope. | S5:L1; S2:L2 | | C11 | R11 | Two prospective attribution questions: for example, who the letter's painter was and what evidence supported the newspaper credit. Questions about a possible contract or signature are acceptable without asserting those records exist. | S2:L1-L2; S5:L2 | | C12 | R12 | Source locations supplied, fictional status/prospective publication maintained, no invented discoveries. | Public R12; S1-S5 | ## Direct reasoning and source sufficiency Donation arithmetic is complete: 20 + 35 = 55, then 55 + 45 = 100, and 45/100 × 100 = 45.0%. Dates are internally feasible in the order commission, assistance, installation, later restoration. A photograph of an installed object in 1914 rules out 1961 as its original completion date under the packet's accepted dating convention. It does not identify a painter. Likewise, a restoration caption can contain an incorrect date without that error proving or disproving a particular person's authorship. The task is answerable as a bounded evidence memo precisely because an unknown artist is permitted. Do not impose a hidden requirement to select Vale or Dass, name an artistic style, or locate additional documents. The guide supplies facts and acceptable interpretations, not a full catalogue paragraph.