# DEV-SYN-04 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** [Public packet](../public/DEV-SYN-04-material-flow.md). Hand-authored mass-balance and claims key, not a generated participant review. Apply [common conventions](README.md). | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | Within 700 words, reconciliation table, claim comparison, uncertainty paragraph. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | P1: 1,200 − 240 = 960 kg. P2: 1,000 − 150 = 850 kg. | S1:L1-L2 | | C3 | R3 | Corrected P2 landfill 70 kg, superseding 80 kg. | S2:L2 | | C4 | R4 | 720 + 120 + 120 = 960; 700 + 80 + 70 = 850. Retention is a destination, not new input or confirmed recycling. | S2:L1-L3 | | C5 | R5 | Incoming-basis yield 720/1,200 = 60%; 700/1,000 = 70%; +10 percentage points. | S1:L1-L2; S2:L1-L2 | | C6 | R6 | Accepted-basis yield 720/960 = 75.0%; 700/850 = 82.4%, rounded. Denominator named. | S1-S2 | | C7 | R7 | Tracked landfill falls 120 − 70 = 50 kg; 50/120 × 100 = 41.7%, not half. | S2:L1-L2; S3:L1 | | C8 | R8 | Products decline from 720 to 700 kg, a 20 kg decline. Higher yield is not greater mass output. | S2:L1-L2; S3:L1 | | C9 | R9 | Rejected destinations and other site waste absent; internal retention is not verified recycling. Cannot infer whole-site landfill or confirmed diversion. | S2:L3; S3:L2; S4:L1; S5:L1 | | C10 | R10 | Mix/composition changed alongside sorting; no causal effect or future prediction established. | S4:L2 | | C11 | R11 | Two specific missing items from S5 or equivalent packet-grounded questions. No new measurements asserted. | S5:L2 | | C12 | R12 | Source locations and derived inputs cited; fictional/proposed review status intact. | Public R12; S1-S5 | ## Direct reasoning and source sufficiency Both mass balances close exactly with the corrected 70 kg value. Using the old 80 kg would produce 860 kg against 850 accepted, so the correction is substantive. Yield improves on either stated basis even while product mass falls; these are compatible statements because incoming/accepted mass also falls. The landfill percentage reduction uses the original 120 kg as denominator, not the new 70 kg or all incoming material. The known 240 kg and 150 kg rejections have unknown destinations. Assigning them all to landfill, all to recycling, or assuming retained material is already recycled would add evidence the packet does not contain. The required task is feasible as a qualified review; no site-wide total, emission factor, or preferred environmental recommendation is a hidden criterion.