# DEV-CON-04 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** [Public packet](../public/DEV-CON-04-token-desk.md). Hand-authored rule and balance key, not a worker procedure or real transaction. Apply [common conventions](README.md). | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | Within 900 words; required flow, roles/records, eligibility and cases. No secret heading names. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | Usable excludes expired credits; original expiry retained; no cash or transfer. | S1:L1-L2 | | C3 | R3 | Entire redemption covered before debit; otherwise no partial debit/overdraft. | S1:L2 | | C4 | R4 | Earliest-expiring unexpired lots first, source amounts recorded. | S1:L2; S2:L1 | | C5 | R5 | Identical ID retry reuses receipt without new debit/benefit; altered details refused/logged. | S2:L2 | | C6 | R6 | Unfulfilled only; exact original lots restored, unchanged expiry, linked cancellation event, no cash. | S3:L1-L2 | | C7 | R7 | Expired restoration can exist in history but not usable balance; original receipt stays. | S3:L1-L2 | | C8 | R8 | Clerk normal events; auditor verifies/corrects display; no discretionary credit grant. | S2:L1; S3:L1; S4:L1 | | C9 | R9 | Correct display to verified ledger, not ledger by issuing +2 credits. | S4:L1; S5:L4 | | C10 | R10 | Q1 stays usable 6; Q2 usable 2, deny 4 without debit; Q3 prospective restore 3 expired, usable 0; Q4 prospective display 6, ledger remains 6. None asserted executed. | S5:L1-L4; S1-S4 | | C11 | R11 | S4 minimum fields, original/corrective events linked, no outside payment/personal data. | S4:L2 | | C12 | R12 | Rule and case references supplied, fictional prospective status maintained. | Public R12; S1-S5 | ## Direct reasoning and source sufficiency Q1 has an existing debit; a repeat is not another 4-credit event, so 6 does not become 2. Q2's recorded total is 5 + 2 = 7 but only 2 is usable; 2 < 4, so no authorized partial redemption exists. Q3 can restore 3 to its old lot without reversing time: day 11 is after day 10, so restored usable amount is zero. Q4's discrepancy is 2, but the correction target is the display; issuing an extra 2 in the ledger would incorrectly turn 6 into 8. These independent cases need no unspecified cash value, identity fields, future earnings, or executed transaction history. A prospective conditional statement is acceptable where staff verification or recording still has to occur. No code, optimum redemption strategy, or additional cancellation entitlement is a hidden scoring obligation.