# DEV-SYN-03: Elder Quay mural attribution dossier **Family:** source-grounded synthesis. **Version:** 1.0, immutable. **Provenance:** hand-authored fictional historical records and people; not archival discoveries or real historical claims. IDs are local to this task. ## Immutable assignment Prepare a short evidence memo and proposed catalogue paragraph about a fictional mural. Distinguish commission, installation, restoration, funding, and authorship. Use only S1–S5. The catalogue wording must be defensible when the records do not resolve the artist's identity. Do not conduct research or claim a catalogue has been published. ## Public requirements - **R1:** Keep the combined deliverable within 650 words, including one proposed catalogue paragraph of at most 80 words and a supporting memo. Count whitespace-separated words throughout, excluding punctuation-only table separators. - **R2:** Give the supported commission, installation, and restoration dates as distinct events. - **R3:** Explain Iona Vale's documented commissioning role without converting that role into proven authorship. - **R4:** Explain what Anik Dass's letter establishes about assistance and what it leaves unresolved about the painter. - **R5:** Discuss why the newspaper's phrase “by Iona Vale” is insufficient on its own to resolve authorship in this packet. - **R6:** State what the dated unsigned photograph establishes and avoid inferring the artist from it. - **R7:** Reconcile the three donations, give their total in the ledger's nominal crowns, and give the largest donor's share to one decimal place. Do not treat donations as proof of authorship or convert them to modern purchasing power. - **R8:** Keep authorship unresolved in the proposed catalogue paragraph; a carefully qualified reference to the later attribution is optional. Do not name a confirmed artist. - **R9:** Explain why the 1961 caption cannot supply the original completion date and distinguish that error from the separate uncertainty about authorship. - **R10:** Make the source hierarchy for dates explicit: use the dated contemporaneous records over the conflicting later caption; do not assume every contemporaneous phrase proves every claim. - **R11:** Identify two prospective research questions about unresolved attribution or the ambiguous newspaper wording without inventing new records or completed searches. - **R12:** Cite source IDs and line locations for factual assertions and calculations. Use only the fictional packet, and claim neither real discoveries nor an executed publication. ## Complete authorized source packet ### S1 — Dated commission ledger - **L1:** Entry dated 1912: “Iona Vale, commission coordinator, authorized the quay mural.” No artist is named. - **L2:** The commission received 20 nominal crowns from the Dock Guild, 35 from the Ferry Circle, and 45 from the Market Trust. These are the complete donation entries; the ledger does not identify payments to an artist or modern currency equivalents. ### S2 — Letter and newspaper - **L1:** A letter dated 1913 and signed Anik Dass says, “I assisted the painter on the quay mural.” It names neither the painter nor the kind of assistance and does not claim sole authorship. - **L2:** A 1914 newspaper item calls it “the quay mural by Iona Vale.” The packet does not establish whether “by” denotes artistic authorship or association with the commission. No signature, interview, or corroborating artist record accompanies the item. ### S3 — Installation record and photograph - **L1:** A dated 1914 facilities entry records installation of the quay mural. It contains no artist credit. - **L2:** A photograph labeled 1914 shows the installed mural. The visible work is unsigned, and the image contains no artist identification. The label's date is accepted as given for this task. ### S4 — Restoration file and later caption - **L1:** A 1961 work order records restoration of the already installed mural, not a new commission or original creation. - **L2:** A display caption produced after the restoration says, “Completed by Iona Vale in 1961.” It supplies no supporting attribution record. Its completion date conflicts with the 1914 installation record and photograph. ### S5 — Dossier scope - **L1:** For dates, the dated commission ledger, installation entry, and restoration work order take precedence over the later caption. The packet does not resolve artistic authorship; neither a coordinator title nor the ambiguous newspaper phrase independently proves it. - **L2:** No further letters, contracts, signatures, interviews, donor conditions, or biographies are supplied. A question about such evidence may be proposed, but its existence or content must not be asserted.