# DEV-CON-01 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** Public packet: [lending procedure](../public/DEV-CON-01-lending-procedure.md). Provenance: hand-authored policy interpretation and prospective case keys, not model outputs or executed depot actions. Apply the [common conventions](README.md). ## Criterion mapping and acceptable handling | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | Within 950 words, five named sections, four ticket traces within Exceptions. A role table or transition table is optional. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | Coordinator: intake/communication; custodian: physical checks, allocation acknowledgment, handover, inspection; supervisor: specified repair release and individual extension decision only. | S2:L1; S4:L2 | | C3 | R3 | Maximum two kits for three inclusive days; D2 replaces four kits/five days. No deposits, payments, or identity documents. | S1:L1-L3 | | C4 | R4 | Physical availability plus custodian allocation acknowledgment precedes reservation. Issued, reserved, and Hold units are unavailable; waiting does not promise a kit. | S1:L4; S2:L1-L2 | | C5 | R5 | Normal Requested → Reserved → Issued → ReturnPending → Closed; Requested → Closed withdrawal and Reserved → Closed cancellation with release acknowledgment. No new status; distinguish metadata flags. | S2:L2-L3, L5-L6 | | C6 | R6 | Physical return recorded by coordinator, handoff to custodian, inspection acknowledgment before returned-issued closure/availability. Pre-issue cancellations remain the explicit exception, not an inspection loophole for issued kits. | S2:L3, L5-L6 | | C7 | R7 | Damage leads to Hold and quarantine; after repair, supervisor authorization returns it to ReturnPending; custodian reinspection is still needed before Closed/availability. No invented replacement promise. | S2:L4; S1:L4 | | C8 | R8 | Overdue flag on Issued; notify borrower and custodian. No automatic closure, presumed return, or fee. | S4:L1 | | C9 | R9 | Only supervisor may grant at most one day before due time with no later-reservation conflict; record the case decision and revised date if approved. No standing extension right. | S4:L2 | | C10 | R10 | All four cases handled prospectively as below. Equivalent descriptions and order are acceptable. | S5:L1-L4 together with S1-S4 | | C11 | R11 | Includes all minimum fields from S3:L1; active records retained until closure; remove name/alias and contact route seven days later, retain non-identifying operations. No extra personal data. | S3:L1-L2 | | C12 | R12 | Operative rules and case interpretations attributed to public lines; no extra fees, gatekeepers, eligibility conditions, powers, or claims of completed action. | Public R12; all S1-S5 | ## Manual case and consistency key For Q1, 4 + 1 + 1 = 6 distinct unavailable kits out of six. Available stock is zero. The coordinator should retain Requested (optionally mark waiting), communicate unavailability, and seek a future custodian availability acknowledgment before any reservation. “Reserve after an actual release is acknowledged” is acceptable; silently reserving a seventh kit or forecasting a guaranteed return is not. For Q2, the custodian should record ReturnPending → Hold and quarantine the damaged kit. A future path can be described conditionally: repair, supervisor repair-release decision, Hold → ReturnPending, custodian reinspection, then closure only if inspection permits it. The packet does not establish that repair or release has happened. A replacement can be considered only if independently confirmed stock exists; no replacement is promised here. For Q3, the coordinator should keep Issued, mark overdue, and notify the borrower and custodian. A later physical return would start the ordinary ReturnPending/inspection path; it is not a present fact. For Q4, the supervisor should deny the extension because a later reservation conflicts. Issued and the original due date remain unchanged; the decision and reason would be recorded and communicated by the coordinator. No approval or denial should be claimed as already recorded. The state system is consistent: pre-issue cancellation has an explicit release acknowledgment but needs no physical-return inspection; issued returns require inspection; damaged returns cannot skip reinspection after supervisor release. A normal pickup on day 1 has day 3 as its due day, not day 4. These checks require no outside operational, legal, or data-retention rules. Formatting, queue order, notification channel beyond the permitted contact route, and exact wording of acknowledgments are not hidden scoring requirements.