# DEV-SYN-01 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** Public packet: [archive brief](../public/DEV-SYN-01-archive-brief.md). Provenance: hand-authored answer key derived from the fictional public notes, not an executed worker response. Apply the [common conventions](README.md). ## Criterion mapping and supported answers | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | At most 650 words using the five named sections. Tables may appear inside them; no required prose style. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | A, B, or deferral with two supported considerations. A may be justified by lower listed cost and optional training headroom, conditional on supervisor confirmation. B may be justified by the inclusive staffing/supplies quote and simpler external booking, without claiming better accuracy. Deferral may cite unresolved resources or quality evidence, without asserting the pilot is impossible. | S1:L1-L3; S2:L1-L3; S3:L1-L2; S4:L1-L3; S5:L1-L2 | | C3 | R3 | Current backlog 168; earlier 140 is explicitly superseded by the signed count. | S1:L2 | | C4 | R4 | Maximum 60 distinct records; 60 / 168 × 100 = 35.7% to one decimal. This is maximum coverage, not promised completion; a full 60 would leave 108 unchecked records. The 108 figure is optional, not separately required. | S1:L1-L3 | | C5 | R5 | In-house 6/40 = 15%; contractor 3/20 = 15%. Neither equal rates nor smaller raw counts establish comparative accuracy. | S4:L1-L3 | | C6 | R6 | A: 120 + (12 × 18) + (2 × 85) + 48 = USD 554. B: 620 + 80 = USD 700. Currency and charging periods must be clear. Do not add A's rental or assistant costs to B. | S2:L1-L2; S3:L1 | | C7 | R7 | A plus optional training: 554 + 96 = USD 650, fits. B plus optional training: 700 + 96 = USD 796, exceeds ceiling by USD 46. Training is not mandatory and has no demonstrated benefit. | S1:L1; S5:L1-L2 | | C8 | R8 | A base leaves USD 196; A plus training leaves USD 100; B base leaves USD 50. An acceptable recommendation selects a feasible bundle or defers. Exact headroom need not be stated if budget implications are otherwise explicit and correct. B plus training is not an authorized recommendation. | S1:L1; S2:L1-L2; S3:L1; S5:L1 | | C9 | R9 | Three ordered stages: authorize/confirm applicable resources, select and check at most 60 records, review flags/document decisions. Conditional next steps for a deferral are acceptable. | S1:L3; S2:L3; S3:L2 | | C10 | R10 | Identifies different record sets (handwritten versus typed), different flag definitions, and no shared correctness reference. These prevent a justified accuracy ranking or causal claim. Mentioning nonrandom selection is additionally supported but is not a separate required item. | S4:L1-L3 | | C11 | R11 | A supervisor availability remains unconfirmed; B has no guaranteed accuracy or flag-resolution result. Neither is invented as resolved. | S2:L3; S3:L2 | | C12 | R12 | Material facts/calculation inputs trace to public locations; estimates remain estimates and proposed actions remain prospective. No external facts or executed-outcome claims. | Public R12; all S1-S5 | ## Manual arithmetic and consistency check Route A's chargeable assistance is 12 × 18 = 216. Two weeks of stand rental cost 2 × 85 = 170, giving 120 + 216 + 170 + 48 = 554. Route B's transport is additional to its inclusive quote: 620 + 80 = 700. Adding 96 yields 650 and 796 respectively. Both base routes fit 750; only A's training-inclusive bundle fits. No tax, labor donation, or discount has to be invented to reach these totals. The maximum pilot coverage is 60/168 = 5/14, or approximately 35.714%, so the public rounding target is 35.7%. Both sample flag fractions are exactly 0.15. They are descriptive rates for different exercises, not measurements of accuracy. A conditional recommendation is feasible because the public assignment requires a decision brief, not a guarantee that staffing or booking has already been secured. No particular route, additional risk, or optional residual-backlog calculation is a hidden scoring obligation.