# DEV-PLAN-03 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** [Public packet](../public/DEV-PLAN-03-water-allocation.md). Hand-authored balance/capacity key, not a generated operational plan. Apply [common conventions](README.md). | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | Within 850 words; decisions, separate daily ledgers, cost, uncertainty. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | Monday fresh 350; Tuesday fresh 450; Wednesday fresh 250 and recovered 50. Total fresh 1,050, recovered 50, combined 1,100 litres. | S1:L1-L2 | | C3 | R3 | All dye demand fresh; no recovered supply before Wednesday for earlier cleaning. | S1:L2; S4:L1 | | C4 | R4 | Wednesday cleaning uses exactly the required 50 recovered; no dye or cross-tank transfer. | S1:L2 | | C5 | R5 | Select whole A on Tuesday and B on Wednesday; no C or invented supply/time change. | S3:L1-L2; S2:L2 | | C6 | R6 | Fresh after Monday use 50; Tuesday receipt gives 550, closing 100; Wednesday receipt gives 400, closing 150. All receipt maxima ≤700 and closes ≥50. | S1-S3 | | C7 | R7 | Recovered Wednesday receipt 150 ≤200, consumption 50, final 100; final fresh 150. Separate reserve accounting. | S2:L1; S4:L1; S1:L2 | | C8 | R8 | C would give 400 + 800 = 1,200 at Monday dawn, above 700 by 500. No dumping, splitting, or pre-receipt use permitted. | S2:L1-L2; S3:L2 | | C9 | R9 | A USD 80, B USD 60, handling USD 10; no fictitious stock cost. | S3:L1; S4:L1-L2 | | C10 | R10 | Total USD 150; headroom 155 − 150 = USD 5. | S4:L2; S3:L1 | | C11 | R11 | Receipts/demand conditional, delay risk, no actual-use claim. | S5:L1 | | C12 | R12 | Locations cited and grade-specific ledgers/prose agree. | Public R12; S1-S5 | ## Direct conservation and feasibility check Monday closes at 400 − 250 − 100 = 50 fresh. A is necessary: without Tuesday's 500, 50 cannot cover Tuesday's 450. With A, 50 + 500 − 450 = 100. B is also necessary: Wednesday requires 250 fresh and a closing reserve of at least 50, more than Tuesday's 100; the only feasible available fresh receipt is B's 300. Wednesday fresh closes at 100 + 300 − 250 = 150. Recovered closes at 150 − 50 = 100. Fresh conservation is 400 + 500 + 300 = 1,200 available minus 1,050 consumed = 150. Combined conservation adds 150 recovered, then subtracts all 1,100 demand, leaving 250 across tanks. Fresh receipt peaks 550 and 400 stay within 700; recovered peaks 150 within 200. Within a day consumption only decreases stock, so checking the receipt peak and daily close suffices here. Offer C cannot become feasible merely because its quoted price is lower per litre: all 800 must arrive before Monday use. No hidden conservation loss, cleaning substitute, or reserve transfer is needed for a solution.