# DEV-PLAN-01 assessor guide **Assessor-only. Version 1.0.** Public packet: [exhibit dispatch](../public/DEV-PLAN-01-exhibit-dispatch.md). Provenance: manually derived feasibility and arithmetic key, not a generated participant deliverable or executed schedule. Apply the [common conventions](README.md). ## Criterion mapping and supported answers | Criterion | Public requirement | Supported answer or acceptable alternative | Public support | |---|---|---|---| | C1 | R1 | At most 850 words; schedule and ledger tables, cost breakdown, and assumptions/uncertainties paragraph present. No hidden heading names. | Public R1 | | C2 | R2 | All A/B/C assembly and verification operations present with durations 30/15, 45/15, 30/15 minutes, and verification after its own assembly. No splitting. Any feasible ordering is accepted. | S1:L1-L4 | | C3 | R3 | Ari and Bo assigned to every operation without overlap; Cora additionally assigned to each verification within 09:00–10:00 or 11:00–12:00. | S2:L1-L2 | | C4 | R4 | Every interval lies within 09:00–12:00 and avoids 10:30–10:45. Matching endpoints are allowed. | S2:L1-L3 | | C5 | R5 | A verified by 10:00; B by 11:45; C by 12:00. Equality is allowed; pickups are not moved. | S1:L1-L4 | | C6 | R6 | Lot assembly-start consumption and 10:45 receipt form a nonnegative ledger. For the witness below the balances are (9,22,14) → (5,14,10) → (2,8,7) → (5,12,7) → (0,2,2), in carton/padding/label order. Reordered feasible ledgers accepted. | S2:L3; S3:L1-L3 | | C7 | R7 | Twelve kits total; final 0 cartons, 2 padding units, 2 labels. Do not count verified kits as extra kits. | S1:L1-L3; S3:L1-L3 | | C8 | R8 | 12 cartons × 1.50 = USD 18; 24 padding × 0.40 = USD 9.60; 12 labels × 0.20 = USD 2.40. Total USD 30. | S3:L1; S4:L1 | | C9 | R9 | Crew operation time 150 minutes per person, 5 person-hours total, USD 90. Cora 45 minutes = 0.75 hours, USD 21. Waiting and break uncharged. | S1:L1-L4; S4:L2 | | C10 | R10 | Direct subtotal 30 + 90 + 21 = USD 141; contingency USD 14.10; total USD 155.10; headroom USD 4.90 under USD 160. No extra courier cost. | S4:L1-L3 | | C11 | R11 | Timing and durations explicitly conditional/planned; delay risk acknowledged; no executed-outcome claim. No probability estimate or invented emergency resource required. | S3:L3; S5:L1 | | C12 | R12 | Constraints/calculation inputs cited, tables and prose consistent, no outside resources or optimality/uniqueness claim. | Public R12; S5:L2; all S1-S5 | ## Manual feasibility witness This table demonstrates that the public constraints have a solution. It is an assessor reference, not a required participant schedule or an executed trajectory. | Operation | Start | Finish | People | Why permitted | |---|---|---|---|---| | A assembly | 09:00 | 09:30 | Ari, Bo | Opening stock covers A | | A verification | 09:30 | 09:45 | Ari, Bo, Cora | A assembled; Cora available; ready before 10:00 | | B assembly | 09:45 | 10:30 | Ari, Bo | Remaining opening stock covers B; ends exactly at break start | | Crew break; no operation | 10:30 | 10:45 | — | Mandatory break | | C assembly | 10:45 | 11:15 | Ari, Bo | Receipt available exactly at 10:45 | | B verification | 11:15 | 11:30 | Ari, Bo, Cora | B assembled; verifier available; before 11:45 | | C verification | 11:30 | 11:45 | Ari, Bo, Cora | C assembled; verifier available; before 12:00 | At A assembly start, consuming (4,8,4) leaves (5,14,10). At B start, consuming (3,6,3) leaves (2,8,7). At 10:45 the receipt adds (3,4,0), yielding (5,12,7); C consumes (5,10,5), leaving (0,2,2). Stock is nonnegative at every event. C cannot assemble from the pre-receipt balance, which contains only two of its five cartons and eight of its ten padding units. There are valid alternatives. For example, after the break the crew can wait until 11:00, verify B from 11:00–11:15, assemble C from 11:15–11:45, and verify C from 11:45–12:00. It meets all deadlines; waiting is uncharged. Alternatively, in the first witness the two final verifications can swap order: C 11:15–11:30 and B 11:30–11:45. Both use the same resources and costs. Assess any other submitted schedule against the public constraints, not against a preferred answer-key ordering. ## Manual cost check Assembly totals 30 + 45 + 30 = 105 minutes; verification totals 15 + 15 + 15 = 45 minutes. Each crew member therefore works 150 productive minutes = 2.5 hours. Two members × 2.5 hours × USD 18 = USD 90. Cora's 45/60 hour × USD 28 = USD 21. Consumed material costs are 18 + 9.60 + 2.40 = USD 30, not a valuation of all stock on hand. Thus direct cost is 141, contingency 14.10, and planned total 155.10. The positive difference from the ceiling is 160 − 155.10 = 4.90. These are exact arithmetic consequences of fictional planning inputs, not observed expenditure or measured completion performance.